Review of Backroad Bicycling in Eastern Pennsylvania: 25 Rides for Touring and Mountain Bikes (Backroad Bicycling Series)

Backroad Bicycling in Eastern Pennsylvania: 25 Rides for Touring and Mountain Bikes (Backroad Bicycling Series)
Average Rating: 4.0 Total Reviews: 1
More Information

this could be so much more user friendly than it is

On: 2007-05-29

Ive enjoyed using this book; I have been on about five of the suggested rides, and enjoyed them all. In some cases they made me aware of areas of the region that I had ignored, and so Im very grateful to the author. And I plan to buy the guides to adjacent regions as well.

So what follows is intended as very friendly constructive criticism, in hopes of a second edition, and perhaps general improvement of the series.

First, PLEASE could the maps not be detailed. Yesterday we tried the Ringing Rocks route. The instructions all depend on knowing the names of particular roads (all, for a miracle, clearly marked by the highway department) but those names are mostly NOT on the map. So its very hard to know where you are. In this case we wanted to turn back half way, and joint the canal in the middle of the route instead of doing the whole 26 miles, but there was no indication on map of what the names of the relevant roads are.

Second, and I know this is hard in all such matters, but please write the directions for getting to the starting place in such a way that someone coming for the first time will absolutely get a good start. For example, in the Ringing Rocks instruction, why not say "theres an enormous white Baptist church where Cafferty Rd meets PA 32. And tell us which way to go in starting out: "Start at the parking lot" is much more helpful if you say where to go (North ? south?)

Im thinking of getting a GPS to complement the book. But in a perfect world, especially for beginners, that surely shouldnt be necessary.

Third, why not make clear which rides can easily be shortened. The Ringing Rocks route can easily be two rides of half the distance, but only the map (inadequate, see above) makes that clear. The Delaware River Canal Towpath Route never even mentions (and its not marked on the map) that there are places to cross which, again, can make the ride into a series of much shorter ones.

The book is clearly intended for beginners. We get a guide to biking in Center City Philadelphia, and were told about Fairmount Park and the Schylkill. So why not offer as many short rides as possible??